5 Killer Anniversary Gifts for Your True Crime-Obsessed Fiancé

Finding a romantic gift for a fiancé who spends their nights analyzing cold cases can be a challenge. You want to celebrate your love while acknowledging their unique passion for mystery. Balancing romance with a fascination for the macabre is tricky, but these picks are sure to hit the mark.

Top Pick #1

Hunt A Killer Membership

$30 - $150
Search Price

It transforms your anniversary evening into an immersive detective experience you can solve together as a team, strengthening your partnership.

Top Pick #2

Personalized 'Partner in Crime' Wall Art

$20 - $50
Search Price

A clever play on words that celebrates your romantic bond while nodding to their favorite genre in a stylish, home-friendly way.

Top Pick #3

MasterClass: John Douglas Teaches Profiling

$180/year
Search Price

Offers deep professional insights from the legendary FBI profiler, perfect for a fiancé who loves the psychological aspect of real-life mysteries.

Top Pick #4

Murder Mystery Dinner Date Night Kit

$25 - $60
Search Price

Allows you to host a private, theatrical anniversary dinner where you both play roles and solve a crime over a home-cooked meal.

Top Pick #5

City Investigative Walking Tour

$40 - $100
Search Price

An adventurous date night experience that gets you out of the house to explore local history and unsolved mysteries in your own city.