5 Killer Christmas Gift Ideas for Your True Crime Loving Crush

Choosing a gift for a crush who devours true crime can feel like solving a cold case. You want to show you listen to their passions without coming on too strong. These picks balance their love for mystery with the thoughtful charm needed to make a great holiday impression.

Top Pick #1

Hunt A Killer Immersive Mystery Set

$30 - $150
Search Price

This interactive experience allows you to solve a fictional murder case together, making it the perfect bonding activity for a low-pressure date.

Top Pick #2

True Crime Podcast Themed Coffee Mug

$15 - $25
Search Price

A mug featuring a witty phrase like 'I'd Pause My Favorite Podcast For You' is a sweet, subtle way to hint at your feelings.

Top Pick #3

Forensic Science Evidence Bag Tote

$20 - $35
Search Price

It is a practical yet stylish accessory that shows you recognize their niche interest while being a useful item for everyday life.

Top Pick #4

Unsolved Case Files Game

$25 - $30
Search Price

These standalone games are highly immersive and provide a cinematic experience that will keep your crush entertained for hours during the winter break.

Top Pick #5

Cozy 'Listening To True Crime' Sweatshirt

$35 - $55
Search Price

Perfect for a crush who loves comfort, this sweatshirt allows them to signal their hobby to the world while staying warm and cozy.