5 Killer Valentine's Day Gifts for Your True Crime Obsessed Crush

Finding the right gift for a crush who loves true crime is like solving a high-stakes cold case. You want something thoughtful without being creepy, showing you pay attention to their dark interests while keeping the vibe light and romantic. It’s a delicate balance to strike this Valentine's Day.

Top Pick #1

Unsolved Case Files Game

$25 - $35
Search Price

It's an interactive way to spend time together while testing your collective detective skills on a fictional cold case.

Top Pick #2

Custom True Crime Illustration

$40 - $70
Search Price

A personalized piece of art featuring them as a detective shows you put real thought into their specific hobby.

Top Pick #3

Stay Sexy, Don't Get Murdered Enamel Pin

$10 - $15
Search Price

A small, low-pressure gift that references a popular podcast and signals that you pay attention to their favorite media.

Top Pick #4

True Crime Themed Soy Candle

$15 - $25
Search Price

Sets a cozy, atmospheric mood for a documentary marathon while adding a subtle touch of mystery to their room.

Top Pick #5

Hunt A Killer Starter Set

$30 - $50
Search Price

This provides a perfect excuse for a follow-up date to solve clues together, turning a hobby into a shared experience.