5 Killer Valentine's Day Gifts for the True Crime Obsessed Boyfriend

Finding a romantic gift for a man whose browser history is full of cold cases and forensic analysis can be daunting. You want to celebrate your love without clashing with his dark interests. We’ve curated gifts that bridge the gap between heartfelt affection and his fascination with the macabre.

Top Pick #1

Hunt A Killer Mystery Box

$30 - $150
Search Price

It transforms a standard date night into an immersive investigation, allowing you both to solve a cold case together.

Top Pick #2

Serial Killer Trivia Card Game

$15 - $25
Search Price

A fun and dark way to test his knowledge of famous cases during a cozy night in with a bottle of wine.

Top Pick #3

Forensic Science Heat-Changing Mug

$15 - $22
Search Price

This practical gift reveals hidden crime scene evidence when filled with hot coffee, perfect for his morning podcast sessions.

Top Pick #4

Custom Evidence Bag Gift Wrap

$10 - $20
Search Price

A creative and thematic way to package smaller Valentine's treats that shows you pay attention to his specific interests.

Top Pick #5

FBI Profiling MasterClass Subscription

$15 - $20 per month
Search Price

Gives him access to real-world experts like John Douglas, moving his interest from casual watching to professional-level insight.